Photo_080308_001_small
this is a featured post by a Dogtime blogger

 

Let me state up front that I'm not upset the Obamas didn't adopt a dog from a shelter or rescue group. It would have been wonderful if they did, but because I love dogs so much, I'm grateful they brought one into their home and perhaps encouraged others to do the same thing.

On the other hand, I can see how a rescue would have done so much to ease the overcrowding at shelters around the country. If the First Family had found their dog at a shelter rather than a kennel, it might have provoked a significant interest in rescuing. Too many dogs need homes.

So maybe it's understandable that so many were upset when the Obamas adopted Bo, the Portuguese Water Dog puppy who will be formally introduced to the country on Tuesday. He isn't a mutt and isn't from a shelter. But he's darn cute.

He didn't work well with his first family, so the kennel essentially is re-homing him. That doesn't make him a rescue, but he clearly was in need of a loving family.

Here's what Wayne Pacelle, president of the Humane Society of the United States, told the Christian Science Monitor: "Clearly our best hope was that (President Obama) would go to a shelter or a breed-rescue group. He didn't do that, but he also didn't go to a pet store or puppy mill either. It's a gray area."

But Abbie Moore of Adopt-a-Pet.com considered it a missed opportunity. "If Obama had adopted a pet from a shelter, it could have been the turning point for the pet-overpopulation problem in this country," she said. "With pet relinquishment up 20 to 30 percent due to the poor economy, pets in shelters can use all the help they can get."

What do you think? Should the First Family have rescued a dog?

 

Default User Photo
April 13, 2009, 3:58 pm
Although "Bo" was not adopted from a shelter, I agree that it is important that he has a wonderful new home. As the parent of a child with allergies who has been looking for a dog to adopt that has hair and not fur, I have had extreme difficulty locating a dog that fits this description at the local animal shelters, Craigslist, Petfinders etc. My five year old reminds me daily that she wants a dog. I bet the Obama's just got worn down by their daughters' want for a dog and got a dog that would work for their family.
Jpgautiebody_small
April 13, 2009, 4:40 pm
USA
My concern is will it be well-trained. This especially since the previous owners didn't work out. Why? Might the poor little thing be handed over again to a 3rd set of owners or banished to one of the alternate family houses? From what I've seen on documentaries of some of the previous presidential pets, it is apparent that they can be a little naughty (chewing, nipping reporters, having the run of the house). This is, in part I believe, because there is no single person in charge who knows what he/she is doing with the pets since presidents are crazy-busy and so are their families. And we all know just because a pup goes to obedience school doesn't make it mind until the pet parents take on the training themselves, consistently. Oh, this baby is so cute. I have no idea what temperament this breed usually exhibits but lets hope it's not one seen lunging on its leash or pooping on the lawn at White House press conferences like previous presidential pets. Presidential pet parents are no different from we commoners---if that pup ends up with behavioral problems, it's the owners fault, not the dog's. But right now I am glad it got a home.
Anonymous
April 14, 2009, 2:51 pm
Poor President Obama - he's darned if he does and darned if he doesn"t. I'm sure he has many more important problems that he needs to concentrate on. Let's wish him and his family and their new pet muh joy and happiness.
Anonymous
April 14, 2009, 7:33 pm
Well, this has been a long discussed issue and finally it has come to an end. The President and the First Lady had to consider the health of their daughter first. This seriously limited their options. They did the right thing. The fact that they have welcomed a pet into their home says a lot. Many families will follow their lead and welcome a new member into their home. Welcome Bo!!
Anonymous
April 14, 2009, 8:34 pm
Wayne Pacelle...His opinion is most valued by...him. The rest of the world , not so much. Especially me. They got a dog from a reputable breeder. They obtained a dog which will meet their expectations. They obtained a dog from a source which is not part of a problem but part of a solution., i.e., they are breeders who care enough to insist on being an integral part of making sure their puppies produced have an appropriate home. They did nothing wrong and everything right!!! Shelter dogs can be wonderful, but, not for everyone. Shelter dogs are a wild card. The Obama's are in no position to be dealing with wild cards. Now get over it Wayne and all those who criticize anything but their own opinion!
Anonymous
April 15, 2009, 9:45 pm
You obviously do care that the Obama's didn't adopt from a shelter which is why you've brought the issue up. Who the heck cares? I mean really! Just because Obama is now the president...who really cares where he got the dog...what type of dog he got or anything that has to do with this dog? The media featured the breeder, to my surprise. The dog was rehomed because its first owners obviously didn't have a clue how to train the dog or possibly didn't have the funds for a trainer. The Obamas will create a new job for someone...the pooper scooper and the one running after it, feeding it, cleaning it, walking it..training it. If you think the obamas will be a stay at home family caring for this dog...you all have rocks in your head. This dog is nothing more than a prop! Too much emphasis has been placed on this dog! Get over it.
Anonymous
April 18, 2009, 10:53 am
What do you think they pay that person? I'll do it.. if it pays good. My very own stimulus package...wonderful..all for it. I'll take good care of the "Prop".

Add a comment...